Search This Blog

Friday, 11 January 2013

"Hijacked Electoral Commission Have Prepared Their Final Guff For The People"


Jersey States electoral change to go to public



Final proposals for changes to how the States of Jersey is elected are due to be decided in a referendum.
The Electoral Commission has released a final report after its initial findings were put out to public consultation.
It has suggested the government be reduced from 52 to 42 members and the island be split up into six equal electoral districts.
The commission has also recommended condensing the roles of senator, deputy and constable into just one.
Currently senators serve for either six or three years while deputies and constables serve for three years.
If the commission's proposals are accepted the assembly would consist of either solely deputies or a mix of deputies and constables - all of whom would serve a four-year term.
All would be elected in a single general election after the panel concluded that the chance to pass judgement on a government outweighed the benefits of staggered elections, which the island operated before 2011.
The panel, made up of three politicians and three members of the public, has put forward suggested questions for the referendum.
A leaflet, explaining the findings, is due to be sent to all households next week.


Wonder why they are looking so smug?

Abolishing constables
The commission reported the main argument for removing the role of constable from the States was to ensure everyone was elected on a similar basis.
The constables are elected by parish and the elections are not always contested.
The panel said the number of eligible voters in St Helier exceeds the number of eligible voters in the eight smallest parishes.
Concerns were also raised over the separate mixed responsibilities of the constables, who have parish duties as well as their States work.
The commission found constables took on fewer positions of senior responsibility in the assembly.
However, it mentioned this would need to be balanced against concerns that if the role of the constable was diminished, by removing them from the States, the parish and all that it represents could also be diminished.
If large electoral districts were introduced retaining the constables in the States would ensure the continuity of parish representation.
The panel said in the neighbouring island of Guernsey, where parish representatives were removed from the government in 2004, the parish has become a less important institution than it is in Jersey.
It added that it was arguable as to whether one is a consequence of the other.

An online comment worth a look
The Commission intends that the referendum will be held using the SINGLE TRANSFERABLE VOTE system, which is madness and will complicate the outcome even more. You can see how the three options will probably appear on the ballot paper on page 9 of the final report (link below):
There will be THREE options to choose from on the ballot paper, but voters will NOT mark the traditional cross against their preferred option. If they do this, their paper may be classed as spoilt and won’t count. Instead they must write the number ’1′ in the box next to their preferred choice. However, they will also have the choice of adding the number ’2′ in the box next to their second choice. Confusingly, it seems that they will not be able to mark their 3rd choice, so anyone who ranks the 3 options in 1,2,3 preference will likely be spoiling their paper and their vote won’t count.
What is immediately clear, however, is that anyone who wants the current parish electoral districts to remain unchanged and not replaced by super constituencies, or anyone who wants to see the Senators remain in the House (the only possibility for any type of island wide vote in the future) then they must vote for NO CHANGE by writing the number ’1′ in the box next to option C, but not choosing either of the two other options as their second choice.

Suggested referendum questions

Reform option A
  • Parish constables removed from the States
  • 42 States members known as deputies
  • Six large districts, each choosing seven deputies
Reform option B
  • Parish constables continue to be members of the States
  • There will be 42 States members: 30 deputies and 12 parish constables
  • There will be six large districts, each choosing five deputies
Option C: No change
  • The current system will remain
  • There will be 49 States members from 2014
  • It will be made up of eight senators elected island-wide, 29 deputies elected in constituencies and 12 parish constables

Proposed electoral districts

  • District 1: St Helier Vingtaines of du Mont Cochon, du Mont a l'Abbé, de Haut du Mont au Prêtre and du Rouge Bouillon
  • District 2: St Helier Vingtaines of Bas de Haut du Mont au Prêtre, Canton Bas de la Ville and Canton de Haut de la Ville
  • District 3: St Clement, Grouville and St Martin
  • District 4: St Saviour and Trinity
  • District 5: St Lawrence and St John, St Mary and St Ouen
  • District 6: St Brelade and St Peter




No comments:

Post a Comment